NetworkLobbyManager - GamePlayerPrefab only spawned for host

As the title says, when I transition from the lobby scene into the game scene, a game player is only created for the host. This game player exists on the host and all clients, but it is the only one.

Both the lobby player and game player have a network identity with local player authority checked. Here is some relevant networking code for up to the transition:

CustomLobbyManager.cs
NetworkLobbyManager - GamePlayerPrefab only spawned for host